 |
| Con Com Reports |
Thanks to our ConCom monitoring volunteers for their report!
View Conservation Commission meeting Agenda.
The Quincy Conservation Commission was established by City Ordinance to "protect the wetlands, related water resources, and adjoining land areas in the City of Quincy by prior review and control of activities deemed by the Quincy Conservation Commission likely to have significant or cumulatively adverse effect upon wetland values including but not limited to the following: public or private water supply, groundwater, flood control, erosion and sedimentation control, storm damage prevention, water pollution, fisheries, shellfish, wildlife habitat, recreation, aesthetics (the visual quality and appearance of a project and / or quiet enjoyment of undisturbed resource areas), and aqua-culture values (collectively, the "wetland values protected by this ordinance")."
|
|
 |
| Quincy Conservation Commission Meeting Minutes for Oct. 15, 2003, Tom Palmer, Tue Oct 28 05:58:14 2003 |
Quincy CONSERVATION COMMISSION 15 OCTOBER 2003
1. Continued Public Hearing to consider a Notice of Intent filed by Mark and Amy Gorham for the razing of the existing 24' 2” X 11' 0" deck, and construction of a 14' 2" X 22' 0” addition to the existing dwelling, on flow-through foundation on property located at 18 Elcott Road, Quincy, MA. Land Subject to Coastal Storm Flowage.
Site Visit: Saturday, 4 October: No problems were seen.
Speaking in Favor: 0
Speaking Against: 0
Motion to issue an Order of Conditions is 21 days. Motion seconded and passed.
2. Continued Public hearing to consider a Notice Of Intent filed by Maura Doherty for the renovation of the existing dwelling, including the closing and backfilling of the existing septic system, and the construction of an addition and deck to the existing dwelling, on the property located at 172 Rock Island Road, Quincy, MA. Land subject to Coastal Storm Flowage; Coastal Beach; Saltmarsh; 100-Foot Buffer Zone.
DEP File No.: 059-0932 Green Cards Submitted
Site Visit held: 4 October
Fill had been dumped on the property 20 - 25 years ago. Fill composed of construction debris.
Motion to continue Hearing. Motion seconded and passed.
3. REQUEST FOR CERTIFICATE OF COMPLIANCE DEP File No.: 59-0718. Request for Certificate of Compliance filed by Diana Billingsley for a completed two-story addition on piers, drainage work and placement of a storage shed on property located at 28 Essex Street, Quincy, MA.
Certificate of Compliance to be issued based on a successful site visit to be scheduled.
4. Continued Public Hearing to consider a Notice of Resource Area Delineation filed by Marian Manor for the Aged and the Infirm, Inc. for the confirmatiori of the boundaries of wetland resource areas - Bordering Vegetated Wetlands, and Intermittent Stream - on property located at Quarry Hills, Ricciuti Drive, Quincy, MA. Bordering vegetated wetlands, Intermittent Stream, 100-foot Buffer Zone
Possible future problems with run off into intermittent stream that flows into Black’s Creek.
Wetland G was to be cleaned out and capacity increased according to original agreement; allowing more water to be held on site and not flow into adjacent properties that are located downhill, which would ease flooding of these properties.
Motion to accept Wetlands Delineation. Seconded and passed.
5. Notice of Intent filed by Blue Cross/Blue Shield for the construction of a new parking garage, roadway and utility modifications, on property located at 3-37 Enterprise Drive, Quincy, MA,
Salt Marsh, Bordering Vegetated Wetlands, Land subject to Coastal Flowage, Area of Critical Environmental Concern. 200-foot Riverfront Area / Neponset River.
Work Proposal: Removal of old run-off pipe. Remove 4 old drain outflow pipes from existing garage that are no longer in use. Restore 2 drain outflow pipes for proposed garage. Removal of vegetation to create scenic vistas of river. Vegetate with low height native plantings.
Speaking in Favor: Tom Palmer, Neponset River Watershed Association Approves of rehabbing the riverfront. Riverfront Walkway Project: Would like to see a public accessible walkway along the river bank.
Motion to continue Hearing pending a Site Visit: Saturday 25 October at 10: 00. Seconded and passed.
6. Request for Determination of Applicability filed by State Street / SSB Realty, LLC, for jersey barriers, steel bollards, large storage containers, concrete planters, earthen berms, boulders, landscape elements, and fencing, into the surrounding area in order to secure the site perimeter, on property located at 1776 Heritage Drive, Quincy, MA.
Land subject to flooding. 100-foot Buffer Zone to BLSF, 100-Foot Buffer Zone to Intemittent Stream with Bank.
Proposed perimeter security. To develop a hardened perimeter to increase security of property housing State Street Buildings and Power Plant.
Storm Drainage Prevention using steel bollards: 6' diameter posts.
Speaking: Tom Palmer - Neponset River Watershed Association
Question: Is it an intermittent stream or a river? There is riverfrontage on one side of property.
Motion to look into defining river frontage. Any side creek or stream that flows from a river is considered a river.
State Street will agree to designate south side of property as River frontage. Sagamore Creek is a designated river.
7. Notice of Intent filed by Mark Dickinson, North Quincy Transit Associates for the construction of a 1,168-space structured parking garage, 134-space surface parking for the North Quincy MBTA Station, and a privately developed 183-unit residential building with 183 at-grade parking spaces on the northwestern portion of the site, Hancock Street, Quincy, MA. Land Subject to Flooding.
Proposal: Structural Parking Garage,12-story Residential Building
Update storm-water system.
Motion to close hearing and issue an Order of Conditions. Seconded and passed.
8. OTHER BUSINESS
Wheel-wash consistent with Order of Conditions for Marion Manor Project. Wheel-wash for all trucks entering and leaving th property
Motion to issue an Enforcement Order: Tires and wheels of trucks and other construction vehicles shall be washed down every time a vehicle leaves the property; also road to be swept as necessary.
Motion made to issue an Enforcement Order. Seconded and passed.
0 comments | view comments | add comment
|
| Quincy Conservation Commission Meeting Minutes for October 1, 2003, Tom Palmer, Tue Oct 28 05:26:22 2003 |
Quincy CONSERVATION COMMISSION 1 OCTOBER 2003
Notes by Larry Cannon
1. Continued Public Hearing to consider a Notice of Intent filed by Mr. Brian P. O’Connor to demolish a 10' X 15' section of deck and build a 10' x 32’ addition on property located at 75 Post Island Road, Quincy, MA. Resource Areas: Buffer Zone; Salt Marsh.
Site Visit scheduled for Saturday, 20 September
Speaking in favor: 0 Speaking Against:0
Motion to accept and issue an Order of Conditions.
2. Public Hearing to consider a Notice of Intent filed by Mark and Amy Gorham for the razing of the existing 24 ‘ 2" X 22' 0" deck, and construction of a 14' 2" X 22' 0" addition to the existing dwelling, on flow-through foundation, on property located at 18 Elcott Road, Quincy, MA. Land Subject to Coastal Storm Flowage.
Speaking in favor: 0 Speaking Against: 0
Motion to continue following a Site Visit on Saturday, 4 0ctober at 9:00; seconded and passed.
3. Public Hearing to consider a Notice of Intent filed by Maura Doherty for the renovation of the existing dwelling, including the closing and backfilling of the existing septic system, and the construction of an addition and deck to the exiting dwelling, on the property located at 172 Rock Island Road, Quincy, MA.
Land subject to Coastal Storm Flowage; Coastal Beach; Salt Marsh; 100-Foot Buffer Zone.
100-Foot Buffer Zone to be contained with Hay Bales.
Coastal Beach and Salt Marsh - No work planned in these areas.
Speaking in favor: 3
Speaking Against: 6
Concerns:
1. Flooding as a result of excess construction in the area.
2. Can the saturation points be maintained.
3. Size of the asphalt driveway.
4. Water seepage into neighboring basements.
5. Mansionizing and blocking of views.
6. Beach erosion
7. Leo Kelly: Quincy Beaches and Coastal Commission: Too many large projects along the waterfront.
Motion made and seconded for a Site Visit 4 October at 9:30.
4. Continued Public Hearing to consider a Notice of Intent filed by Frederick Paul McDonald for the construction of an addition to an existing three family dwelling and the reconstruction of a crushed stone/gravel driveway and parking areas for seven vehicles and grading activities, on property located at 1241-B Sea Street, Quincy MA. No alteration of the coastal bank is being proposed.
Resource Areas: Buffer Zone; Coastal Bank.
Speaking in Favor: 0
Speaking Against: 0
Motion to accept the plans as revised, with alterations as needed. Pavers will cut down the erosion and if put down correctly they will not be disturbed, ever.
Motion to Close the Hearing and issue an Order of Conditions, with further discussion Of materials to be used for parking area.
Seconded and passed.
5. Public Hearing to consider a Notice Of Resource Area Delineation filed by Marion Manor for the Aged and the Infirm, Inc. for the confirmation of the boundaries of wetland resource areas - Bordering Vegetated Wetlands and Intermittent Stream - on property located at Quarry Hills, Ricciuti Drive, Quincy MA.
Bordering Vegetated Wetlands, Intermittent Stream; 100-Foot Buffer Zone.
Sister Mark Lewis (Marion Manor); Robert Fleming, Representing
Delineation of Wetlands: Brad Holmes, BSC Group: Wetlands Specialist
1. Intermittent Stream on property
2. Bordering Vegetated Wetlands
3. No floodplain on property
4. Storm Water Retention Area to be built into project.
Tom Palmer: Friends of the Blue Hills
Q: Are either wetland sites vernal pools?
A: There are no vernal pool certifications on the site and there was no evidence of vernal pool species on the site visit.
Speaking For: 0
Speaking Against: 1 abutter
Concern: Flooding
Motion for Site Visit: 11 October, 9:00 AM; meeting place to be determined.
Hearing continued to 15 October.
6. Continued Public Hearing.
Continued Public Hearing to consider an Abbreviated Notice of Resource Area Delineation filed by Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Massachusetts, Inc, c/o Lawrence A. Healey, for the approval of the following delineated resource areas: Salt Marsh; Bordering Vegetated Wetland; Land Subject to Coastal Storm Flowage; and the 200-foot Riverfront Area, on property located at 3-37 Enterprise Drive, Quincy, MA.
Motion to accept delineation of resource areas - Seconded and Passed.
7. DEP File 59-0795 - Request for Certificate of Compliance flied by Beth Martel, for property located at Elcott Road, Quinsy, MA.
Applicant not present.
8.DEP File 059-0776 - Request for an Extension to the Order Of conditions filed by Paul Hardiman for the property located at 215 Palmer Street, Quincy, MA.
Modified plans with reduction of size from 58 to 44 feet.
Project to be no closer to water than originally planned. No change in shape of foundation.
Existing Order of Conditions extended for 2 years with reduction in size as previously noted.
9. Request for an Emergency Certificate filed by Anthony Wine, 66 Crabtree Road, for the placement of a temporary concrete apron in the setback of Crabtree Road, for the purpose of drainage improvements.
Concerned that the retaining wall could collapse due to continued freezing. Re- enforcing bars are in place. Salt air can corrode the bars and salt will permeate the concrete.
Emergency Certificate requested, because applicant is leaving town.
Motion to issue an emergency certificate, seconded and passed.
10. Albert V. Calcagno - Crane Road and Terne Road - request for the Conservation Commission to purchase several privately owned lots in saltmarsh.
Conservation Commission does not purchase land. Suggested to bring request to the Open Space Committee.
11. Joseph Koch - Request to remove two dead trees adjacent to the Vo-tech parking lot on Coddington Street, and one tree on 17 Plover Road, Quincy,MA.
To restore a drain line that runs beneath the tree - drain line has been crushed by the tree's roots. 12" drain line catches street runoff and drains into the marsh.
Project: To take the tree down and restore the drain pipe.
Motion made to accept the project and allow removal of the tree. Seconded and passed.
1 comments | view comments | add comment
|
| Quincy Conservation Commission meeting minutes for September 17, 2003, Tom Palmer, Wed Oct 1 08:08:41 2003 |
Quincy Conservation Commission Meeting Minutes
September 17, 2003, 7:30 PM
Agenda and Notes
Submitted by Ross Edwards and Larry Cannon
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Attending members: Katherine Shaw, acting Chair; Suzanne Dixon, James Iorio, and Martha King; and Heather Sargent, Enforcement Officer .
_____________________________________________________________________________________
6:45 PM. Executive Session - City Solicitor Monica Conyngham - update
City Solicitor was not able to attend.
7:30 PM. Public hearing to consider a Notice of Intent filed by Mr. Brian P. O’Connor to demolish 10’ X 15’ section of deck and build 10’ X 32’ addition, on property located at 75 Post Island Road, Quincy, MA. Resource Areas: Buffer zone; Salt Marsh.
1. Code: 1.
2. Owner represented self.
3. No obvious environmental impact/concerns.
4. No speakers for or against the project.
5. Site visit scheduled for 9:00 AM Saturday, September 20
6. Action: hearing continued to October 1, 2003.
7:40 PM. Public hearing to consider an Notice of Intent filed by Frederick Paul McDonald for the construction of an addition to an existing three family dwelling and the reconstruction of a crushed stone/gravel driveway and parking areas for seven (7) vehicles and grading activities, on property located at 1241B Sea Street, Quincy, MA. No alteration of the coastal bank is being proposed. Resource Areas: Buffer zone; Coastal Bank.
1. Code: 1
2. Construction details: floor area will be extended but no additional units will be added; hard-packed impervious driveway will be broken up and replaced by pervious gravel surface; construction is “slab on grade; the seven parking spaces will be “non-conforming.”
3. Edward Fleming, attorney, and Zolten Uhaus (spelling uncertain), engineer, representing owner. Mr. McDonald lives on property, rents out two units.
4. No obvious environmental impact/concerns.
5. No speakers came forward for or against the proposal.
6. Site visit scheduled for 9:30 AM Saturday, September 20.
7. Action: hearing continued to October 1, 2003.
7:50 PM. Public Hearing to consider an Abbreviated Notice of Resource Area Delineation filed by Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Massachusetts, Inc., c/o Lawrence A. Healey, for the approval of the following delineated resource areas: Salt Marsh; Bordering Vegetated Wetland; Land Subject to Coastal Storm Flowage; and the 200-foot Riverfront Area, on property located at 3-37 Enterprise Drive, Quincy, MA. DEP 059-0926.
1. Code: 3.
2. Is within Neponset River Protection Area. Will rebuild garage on existing footprint, remove invasive species within resource area that obscures views of Boston, do not plan to work in areas subject to flooding, will otherwise improve landscaping of presently developed property, incorporate snow removal regulations into management of area, and will bring site to DEP specifications. Object of this Notice: to seek advice on delineation, and any restrictions that the Commission might require or advise. “Area of disturbance” is no larger than the present “area of disturbance.”
3. Represented by Jerry Blumenthal and William R. Maher of Judith Nitsch Engineering, Inc.
4. Environmental impacts: the Riverwalk proposed by NepRWA will pass through or close to this property. We should advise them of our concerns and inform them of the Riverwalk plan details.
5. Opposition to project. None immediately. No speakers for or against the proposal. Ross Edwards, 65 Narragansett Rd., Quincy, and member of QEN, mentioned to the proposers the existence of the Riverwalk proposal and offered to provide them more details regarding how it related to the proposal.
6. Site visit: members of the Commission will individually visit the site informally before the next meeting of the Commission.
7. Action: continued to October 1, 2003.
8. Comments: we should provide them with relevant details of the proposed Riverwalk and offer to consult with them about how their proposal will influence the Riverwalk site and what contributions we would like them to make to the Riverwalk.
8:00 PM. Public Hearing to consider a Notice of Intent filed by Patrick Nevins for the addition of a 16’ X 16’ addition to rear of property off of northwest existing structure, on property located at 80 Bicknell Street, Quincy, MA. The proposed project is in the floodplain and, therefore, this Notice of Intent is being filed to meet the requirements under the Quincy Wetlands Protection Ordinance only.
1. Code: 1
3. Owner only.
4. No obvious environmental impact/concerns.
5. No speakers for or against the proposal.
6. No sight visit.
7. Action: unanimously approved.
Other Business properly coming before the Quincy Conservation Commission:
A. Discussion, led by Commissioner Dixon, regarding the Public Shade Tree Act.
Essence of the law: the City Tree Warden , appointed by the Mayor and working under the authority of the City Parks Commission, has the authority to remove trees unless the trees are involved in wetlands, in which case the issue requires review by the Conservation Commission.
Trees at Adams Shore and along Coddington Street were discussed. The Commission requested that Ms. Sergeant evaluate all relevant trees and report on them at the next meeting.
B. At 277 Palmer Street, Quincy, a makeshift boat launching ramp was improperly constructed over City property. The Commission authorized Ms. Sargent to send a notification to the party to remove the ramp.
C. At 47 Sea Avenue, Houghs Neck, Quincy, a large retention wall was observed, from a boat, to have been constructed in the Coastal Zone without approval by the Commission. Ms. Sargent was unanimously voted authority by the Commission to issue an enforcement order regarding the wall (presumably to require appearance by the property owner to explain, and perhaps be ordered to remove the wall).
D. Tracy Dorgan, 108 Sherman St., Monclair District, Quincy, gave an update on the alleged illegal intrusion into the protected area of Montclair Bog by the resident at 150 Sherman St. He is apparently continuing to encroach the area and appears to be removing material from the area with a pickup truck (10-12 loads). The is person also has allegedly intimidated neighbors who object to his intrusion, and he has “beat up one of his neighbors,” according to Ms. Dorgan. This issue will be on the agenda of the next meeting of the Commission.
Notetakers left the meeting at this time, prior to formal adjournment.
0 comments | view comments | add comment
|
| Quincy Conservation Commission minutes for August 20th, 2003, Tom Palmer, Thu Sep 25 23:16:12 2003 |
Quincy Conservation Commission Meeting Minutes
August 20, 2003
Recorded by Larry Cannon
___________________________________________________________________
1. Mallard Road Salt Marsh Restoration
Public Hearing to consider a Notice of Intent filed by the City of Quincy Department of Public Works to restore approximately 0.7 acres of tidally restricted salt marsh on property located at the end of Mallard Road and Post Island Road, Quincy.
Resource Areas: Bordering Vegetated Wetland; Salt Marsh
Purpose: To restore tidal flow to marsh.
Project: Re-grading of marsh to increase tidal flow capacity and flood storage capacity.
Speaking in favor: 4
Speaking against: 0
Motion made to accept. Motion seconded and passed. .
2. Public Hearing to consider Notice of Intent filed by Property RE Company
Location: 2 Curlew Road, Quincy, MA
Resource Areas: Work proposed is in the buffer zone
Project: Removal of concrete block garage and bituminous concrete parking area and construction of a new duplex residential building with gravel driveway and 4 gravel parking spaces on afore mentioned property.
Speaking in favor: 0
Speaking against: 0
Motion made to accept.
Motion seconded and passed.
3. Public Meeting to consider a Request for Determination of Applicability filed by Adrienne M. Brady.
Location: 156 Liberty Street, Quincy, MA
Work proposed is within 100' of the 100-Hundred Year Flood Boundary and 500-Hundred Year Flood Boundary.
Project: Addition of a one-story addition with master bedroom suite and family room adjacent to existing two-story house on afore mentioned property.
Purpose: Resident has health issues prohibiting them access to the second floor.
Speaking in favor: 0
Speaking against: 0
Motion: Negative applicability - Wetlands Act does not apply
Project Approved.
4. Request for Certificate of Compliance filed by Stephen and Sharon Racette for an Order of Conditions, DEP File No. 59-832.
Location: 12 Narragansett Road
Order of Conditions issued.
5. Request for Extension Permit filed by MeadowLand Realty Trust/ David P. Doherty, Jr. for DEP File No. 59-689.
Location: 115-117 Elm Street, Quincy, MA
Extension granted.
6. Request by Jeff Plante of Coler & Colantonio to give a presentation on behalf of Mass. Electric Co. to review project status of DEP File No. 59-855 and to discuss the Performance of remediation activities in three isolated areas of contaminated soil that were encountered during excavation activities at the Field Street Sub station.
Contamination Source: PCB=s from transformer oil.
Excavation for modular building location: 30' X 30' X 2' down.
Permission granted to continue project.
7. Request by Atty. Bob Fleming to discuss preliminary design for potential activities on property located adjacent to the Quarry Hills area. Assessors Map 4126, Parcels 72 and 73.
Property: 8-1/4 acre, PUD Site, known as the Bates parcel
Wetlands on property. Intermittent stream runs through the wetlands. Quarry hole located on site - may need cleaning out.
Informal discussion of Preliminary Design for Marion Manor Project: a Long-Term Care Facility with Independent Living Facilities.
8. Request by Ron Iacubicci, CEO of the Mini Fenway Project organization for an informal Discussion to address the project on property located at 130-170 Ricciuti Drive.
Lot is presently wooded. Zoned Independent A - North, B - South. Partially graveled lot to provide temporary parking for Quirk Auto Auction on adjacent site. Quarry on site has been filed with construction debris; to be cleaned out by The Quarry Hills Assoc.
This will be a phased project: Phase one - Siting of Mini Fenway.
MEETING ADJOURNED: 9:30
0 comments | view comments | add comment
|
| Quincy Conservation minutes for June 18th, 2003, Tom Palmer, Thu Sep 25 22:57:19 2003 |
Quincy Conservation Commission Meeting Minutes
June 18, 2003
Recorded by Courtney Campbell
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Members present:
Kathy Shaw (chairing), Sue Dixon (left early), Martha King, Tom Kelly, Jim Iorio (late), & Heather Sargent (Enforcement Officer). Bill Keener absent.
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Item #1 – Continued Request for Determination of Applicability filed by Dawna Creighton for placement of crushed stone, pavers, or other pervious material on a 20’ x 50’ driveway on property located at 13 Bayswater Road, Quincy, MA (Land Subject to Coastal Storm Flowage)
Applicant present
Applicant wants to put either crushed stone or pervious pavers in driveway; not sure yet which
Heather said crushed stone was best option, followed by pavers without grout in between
Applicant seemed to be leaning more towards crushed stone
Con Com wants applicant to call in when she decides which one she’ll use
Voted - act does not apply – Tom & Sue - unanimous
Item #2 – Request for Determination of Applicability filed by Donald Maggioli for the installation of a foundation for a fireplace, and to replace an existing fence on the roadway and along the side of the house on property located at 155 Bayside Road, Quincy, MA (100-Foot Buffer Zone of Coastal Bank)
Applicant present
Just fireplace is in 100-ft buffer zone
Fence removal across street is not in buffer zone – applicant is not replacing this fence
Proposed construction of a fence on side of house – new fence – 127’
Applicant asked about pavers/crushed stone elsewhere on his property – CC said if no previous Orders of Conditions are on property it might be ok – but applicant would have to come before CC again
Jens Thornton spoke in favor of project – he wants the fence that applicant is proposing to remove part of out – Jens said that the fence is in the road
Edmund Paris – wanted to clarify that existing fence on side of house will remain and new fence built next to it – yes
Voted – act does not apply – Tom & Martha - unanimous
Item #3 - DEP File #59-0882 - Request for Certificate of Compliance filed by John Viera for construction of retaining wall and filling in rear yard at 25 Empire Street, Quincy, MA (Isolated Land Subject to Flooding)
Applicant present
Heather went to see site Monday – she took digital pictures but not sure if they came out yet
Applicant can’t afford completed As-Built plans right now – but he has 3 years to get them in
CC issued partial Certificate of Compliance pending As-Built plans
Item #4 - DEP File # 59-0655 – Request for Certificate of Compliance filed by Maura Doherty for 190 Rock Island Road, Quincy, MA.
Applicant present
Heather has seen site several times – all times have been fine
Project: demolished small house and built new house – site in 100-ft buffer zone – had required haybales – As Built plans were submitted
Certificate of Compliance granted – Tom & Sue - unanimous
Item #5 – Continued Notice of Intent filed by Stephen and Janice Richmond for the construction of 304.5 sq.ft. multi-level deck on the rear of the existing single-family home on property located at 10 Heath Street, Quincy, MA (Land Subject to Flooding and Coastal Storm Flowage)
Dennis Harrington representing applicants and applicants present
Applicant had problem with water in basement – to mitigate, they took up asphalt in backyard and put in crushed stone – fixed flooding problem
Applicant now wants to pave 35’ of the driveway for winter parking use
This paving wasn’t mentioned in notice – it was amended for paper
Retaining wall seems to be taking care of water
Item approved – Tom & Martha – unanimous
Item #6 - Notice of Intent filed by Boston Properties for the restoration of approximately 220’ of eroded bank along Sagamore Creek on the western perimeter of the project site, including bank stabilization and saltmarsh restoration, on property located at 86-108 Myrtle Street, Quincy, MA (Riverfront Area/Neponset River; Bank; Land Subject to Flooding and Land Subject to Tidal Action)
Jeff Poncho representing Boston Properties, John Thomas (Professional Wetlands Scientist) and Allison Flinch both from Beals & Thomas present
DEP # 059-0916
John Thomas presented photograph and spoke about project
Bank in front of Boston Properties is eroding due to the direct wave action from opposite side of stream during spring tide
Looked at various alternatives (armored bank with rip rap, bulkheads, etc.) but because of ACEC they decided on bioengineering techniques – fiber core tubes (20”) and blankets embedded with plant matter and coconut fiber are put in ground
They’re planning to implement this in 50’-75’ stages to see if it works
They’re proposing to restore the bank from in front of property up to old dry dock 220’ downstream
They’re working from the mean high water line back for excavation – trucks will stay on above pavement and grass
Tom Palmer – asked if all 220’ are in bad repair, asked for an aerial photo of site, also mentioned that a goal of the ACEC is to promote public access – Tom asked for a walkway along river to tie into Riverwalk plan – Jeff Poncho shook his head to John Thomas and said that while Boston Properties may listen to Tom’s idea, the walkway is not necessary – Thomas said client might be open to discussion but not as part of this proposal – maybe seperately – Tom will forward Riverwalk plan to him
Jens Thornton said that in the Montclair Marsh Order of Conditions it stated that no fill could be used within 100’ of river or within 20’ from any side creek
Arthur Knowleton – in favor, but was concerned that with a big storm their plan might wash out – he wanted to make sure there was someone in place to repair it if that happens – yes
Site visit scheduled for Friday, June 20th at 6:30 p.m. – meet at end of parking lot at 108 Myrtle St.
Item continued
Item #7 – Notice of Intent filed by Daniel Quirk for demolition of the existing structure, and the filling to grade and paving of the excavation depression, on property located at 577 Southern Artery, Quincy, MA (Riverfront Area/Town Brook; 100-Foot Buffer Zone of Bordering Vegetated Wetland/Bank)
Rudy Pompeo and Mike Chaney representing Quirk present
Project is to tear building down and pave lot
They’ll be using existing drainage in road and catch basins
Site is in riverfront area
Applicant didn’t bring topographical map with him – but does have one
Larry Cannon representing Souther Tide Mill restoration project – asked why they where demolishing building? – what are plans for that site?
Mike Chaney explained that the current restaurant is not doing well – so they’re closing it down, paving lot and will temporarily use it for employee parking – not sure for how long – depends on how Nissan dealership across street does
Site visit scheduled for Wednesday, June 25th at 6:30 p.m.
Item #8 – DEP File #59-0743-Request for Certificate of Compliance filed by Quirk Automotive Dealerships for the property located at 600 Southern Artery, Quincy, MA.
Rudy Pompeo and Mike Chaney present
Mike Chaney said they received their Chapter 91 license
Heather said that some very good changes have been made
Cheney submitted a maintenance agreement signed by Quirk for daily maintenance of vegetation and walkway
Arthur Knowleton – in favor
Certificate of Compliance issued – Jim & Tom - unanimous
Item #9 – Notice of Intent filed by Pat Considine for the legalization of the demolition of the existing dwelling and for the construction of a new, three-family dwelling and garage under, on property located at 94 East Squantum Street, Quincy, MA (100-Foot Buffer Zone of Bordering Vegetated Wetlands/ Inland Bank/Riverfront Area)
Ken _____ engineer present
288 cubic yards of fill will be added to site
project is for a 4 family, not a 3 family – was listed correctly in paper
4th unit is 70 ft from wetland
on site visit – CC saw some standing water
There is a hydraulic connection to Neponset River in area
Frank Coyman (E. Squantum St. resident) said his next door neighbor tried to enlarge their deck years back and was denied by CC – also said previous owner of this property couldn’t put up a garage – wants to know how CC can approve a 4 family house
Applicant demolished old house without going before Con Com
Applicant says he doesn’t need to go before ZBA because it’s zoned as a multi family lot
Applicant doesn’t have building permit yet
Kathy doesn’t like fill going in buffer zone – wants to see drainage info first from DPW for area
Item continued – Jim & Tom - unanimous
Item #10 – Continued Notice of Intent filed by Charles Murphy for the razing of the existing single-family dwelling and construction of a flow-through foundation and placement of a prefabricated dwelling, same footprint, on property located at 59 Edgewater Drive, Quincy, MA. Land Subject to Coastal Storm Flowage; 100-Foot Buffer Zone of a Coastal Beach/Bank
Vetas and Vetas representative and applicant present
They claim that FEMA construction regs are adhered to in the plan
Existing foundation was taken out
Applicant says project will have 0 impact on neighbors
Neighbors are already getting additional flooding
CC wants applicant to add crushed stone around foundation to be sure – layer of crushed stone then 2’ fill on top
Item approved – Tom & Jim - unanimous
Item #11 – Continued - DEP File#59-0614-Quarry Hills Recreation Complex and DEP File #59-0615- MDC Landfill -Requests for Extension Permits and Approval of Quarry Hills Walking Trails Plan.
Dennis Harrington present
Had site visit last night
Section 61 revision?
Still issues with relocation of trails (#614)
Applicant asking for a 3 year extension for #615
#614 continued, #615 extension granted
Item #12 – Continued - DEP File #59-0721-Request for Site Inspection and a Certificate of Compliance for the MWRA Squantum Force Main - Mitigation Project -# 6810.
No one present
CC will issue a partial Certificate of Compliance – they want more info on anodes into Quincy Shore Drive – holes supposed to be filled in 10 months
Item #13 - Dr. Dixon –Discussion of Division of Marine Fisheries Permit to Metropolitan District Commission for Greenberg Bridge – June, 1971, and Ch.91 #6003 - License to MDC for removal of bridge, construction of culvert, seaward channel and groin, to fill a portion of black’s creek and Quincy Bay, Quincy, MA
Postponed
Item #14 - Continued Notice of Intent filed by the Department of Public Works for the cutting and removal of phragmites in preparation of restoring the Parkhurst Street saltmarsh, on property located at Winthrop, Parkhurst and Weymouth Streets, Quincy, MA. Bordering Wetlands Vegetation/Phragmites; and Land Subject to Coastal Storm Flowage
Monica Cunningham (City Solicitor) didn’t show up – have to continue item
Arthur Knowleton asked for an extension to the emergency Order of Conditions that the CC granted him until end of July to remove what’s been cut already – due to all the rain he hasn’t been able to remove cuttings – extension granted
Jay Fink won’t pay for disposal so Arthur will have to pay to remove cuttings himself – can’t leave cuttings on site
Arthur cannot do new cutting until CC says so
Enforcement Officer’s report
150 Sherman Street – tree cutting in Bog – Heather sent an Enforcement Cease and Desist Order to Mr. Cochrane who refused the Order – wants a policeman to deliver next – granted
Shawn Lennon wants to come back to help CC – he’s proposing to revise the Wetlands Protection Act – both for school credit and to help CC – he sees the revision in 3 phases: 1) get input from CC, officials, etc. and research other cities/towns revisions to Wetlands Act, 2) revise, 3) sign off – Kathy said to make sure nothing from original Act was voided – just embellished – CC suggested looking at other Act revisions for cities with similar characteristics as Quincy (Revere, Gloucester, Weymouth, Beverly, etc.) – for school credit he’ll need to work 20 hrs/week for 12 weeks – doesn’t have to be a paid position, but if they can find funds they’d be appreciated – Tom asked for prospectus of how much time on each phase – Tom agreed to be his supervisor for this project
THE NEXT MEETING WILL BE WEDNESDAY, JULY 2nd AT 7:30 P.M.
0 comments | view comments | add comment
|
| Quincy Conservation Commission minutes for June 4th, 2003, Tom Palmer, Thu Sep 25 22:35:09 2003 |
Quincy Conservation Commission Meeting Minutes
June 4, 2003
Recorded by Courtney Campbell
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Members present:
Kathy Shaw (chairing), Jim Iorio, Martha King, Tom Kelly, Bill Keener, & Heather Sargent (Enforcement Officer). Sue Dixon absent.
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Item #1 – Request for Determination of Applicability filed by Dawna Creighton for placement of crushed stone, pavers, or other pervious material on a 20’ x 50’ driveway on property located at 13 Bayswater Road, Quincy, MA (Land Subject to Coastal Storm Flowage)
New item
Con Com requested letter from applicant asking for a continuance – applicant wasn’t able to make tonight’s meeting
No public comment
Continuance granted – Tom made motion, Jim seconded, unanimous approval
Item #2 – Notice of Intent filed by Stephen and Janice Richmond for the construction of 304.5 sq.ft. multi-level deck on the rear of the existing single family home on property located at 10 Heath Street, Quincy, MA (Land Subject to Flooding and Coastal Storm Flowage)
New item
Dennis Harrington representing applicants
Property in a mapped FEMA flow area
No wetlands or wetlands vegetation on site – salt marsh on opposite side of street
Deck will be on sono tube foundation with no bells
Applicant needs a building permit for deck – needs Con Com to approve first
16.7 sq.ft. impacted land – 100 cubic feet of displaced soil
applicant removed paved parking spaces in rear of house and replaced with crushed stone
Diane Cavanaugh – living across street – concerned about excess amount of cars from that house parking on street – says there are more people living there than just a single family
Applicant stated he and his wife live there full time, currently his daughter, her husband, their child, and another homeless friend are staying there temporarily
As soon as Con Com allows them to park in driveway, they will
Jack Bailey – lives nearby – says retaining wall never used to be there – and wants site visit
Harrington commented it’s not a retaining wall – it’s a concrete planter
Field trip scheduled for June 17th at 6:00
Item continued
Item #3 - Notice of Intent filed by Tom and Clare Hynes for the demolition of the existing garage and construction of a 25’ x 45’ single-family dwelling on property located at 50 Bay View Ave., Quincy, MA (100-Foot Buffer to Coastal Bank)
New item
Proposing to raze existing garage and construct a single family house
There will be a full basement (5’ under the ground) – there is now only a slab on grade foundation for garage
Property is above high water mark
ZBA process currently ongoing
1/2 of proposed house is in the 100-foot buffer zone
Abutter spoke (didn’t get name) – she brought around a petition in the neighborhood – no objections or flooding concerns – can attest to the fact that there’s no flooding problem in area
Abutter notification cards submitted
Item approved subject to receiving a final engineering plan – Jim made motion, Tom seconded, unanimous approval
Item #4 - Notice of Intent filed by William and Ann DiMattio for the construction of an addition to the existing single-family dwelling on property located at 9 Lillian Road, Quincy, MA (Land Subject to Flooding)
New item
Tim Brown (builder) representing applicant
Proposed 12’ x 15.5’ addition on sonotubes
Property in flood plain
44” pipe near property but not near addition
16 cubic feet of displaced soil
Doug Gutro – Ward 5 Councillor – this area is not a flooding issue, and it’s a small addition, so he’s in favor
Abutter cards submitted
Item approved – Tom made motion, Jim seconded, unanimous approval
Item #5 – DEP File # 59-0614 – Quarry Hills Recreation Complex and DEP File # 59-0615 – MDC Landfill – Requests for Extension Permits
Robert Cummings representing Quarry Hills, and Dennis Harrington present
Need extension on permits
Showed proposed relocation plan for hiking trails
MDC site has been closed and capped – never certified
Walter Hannon described hiking trails
William Aylward asked about MDC work with Blacks Creek – Cummings said that a scope of work is still being developed with DEP – DEP had wanted a study of offsite impacts
Jim Iorio said visible silt and clay plumes float downstream especially after storms – he’s also seen filtration devices washed out
Site visit scheduled for June 17th at 6:30 – CC will look at hiking trail plan
Item continued
Item #6 - Notice of Intent filed by Charles Murphy for the razing of the existing single-family dwelling and construction of a FEMA-approved, helical pile foundation and placement of a prefabricated dwelling, same footprint, on property located at 59 Edgewater Drive, Quincy, MA (Land Subject to Coastal Storm Flowage; 100-Foot Buffer Zone of a Coastal Beach/Bank)
Applicant present
Con Com is looking for a foundation plan that shows distance between top of helical coil to finished grade
Foundation wall will be 4’ below grade (frost wall)
Con Com had trouble with a similar project – too much room between coil and final grade
Vetas and Vetas is architect – spoke with Martha King – they are experts in helical coils
Applicant needs an engineer to figure out compensatory storage
There are other ways to do a foundation
Site visit scheduled for June 16th at 6:00 p.m.
Item continued – CC wants Vetas and Vetas rep there next time
Item #7 – Notice of Intent filed by Pat Considine for the legalization of the demolition of the existing dwelling and for the construction of a new, three-family dwelling and garage under, on property located at 94 East Squantum Street, Quincy, MA (100-Foot Buffer Zone of Bordering Vegetated Wetlands/Ingland Bank/Riverfront Area)
Applicant presented plan with location of trees
Possible legal problem??
Added stairs down to a wood chip area
CC asked how much fill would be added to site – engineer didn’t know – will have info for next meeting
There is a wet wooded area – but no streams
Kathy Shaw commented the current fill on site felt mushy
Item continued – applicant will have to issue an amended notice (four family, not three) and bust have amount of fill for next meeting
Item #8 – Continued Notice of Intent filed by the Department of Public Works for the cutting and removal of phragmites in preparation of restoring the Parkhurst Street saltmarsh, on property located at Winthrop, Parkhurst and Weymouth Streets, Quincy, MA (Bordering Wetlands Vegetation/Phragmites; and Land Subject to Coastal Storm Flowage)
No DEP # so item continued until next meeting – Tom made motion, Bill seconded, unanimously approved
Item #9 – DEP File # 59-0721 – Request for Site Inspection and a Certificate of Compliance for the MWRA Squantum Force Main – Mitigation Project - #6810
Steve Kasaza representing MWRA present
3 projects: 1) corrosion mitigation of force main sewer on Quincy Shore Drive (#6810), 2) Squantum Pumping Station (#5405), 3) Quincy Pumping Station off Fenno St. (#5407)
Order of Conditions was extended until Nov. 2003
Projects #2 & #3 are done – MWRA wants site visit and Certificate of Compliance for those 2
MWRA wants certificate issued before they loose contact with contractors
Project #1 had a problem, but it will be done by Sept. 2003
Each project has to have its own certificate of compliance
Bill Keener noted that the holes that were dug for project #1 are still open and are deep – he wants them filled
Bill Aylward brought up a drainage issue with the access road leading to project #3 and the bad smell from new pumping station
Jim asked about direct outfall into Blacks Creek – applicant says no
Site visit scheduled for June 16th at 6:30 p.m.
Item #10 – DEP File # 59-0827 – the Finger Company – the Village at Quarry Hills – activity update
Finger Company and HW Moore representatives present
Blue Hill Quarry/Cashmans Quarry – was to be emptied and filled for use as a detention basin
Water and sediment was tested – clean – removed
Solid debris was then encountered – owner’s responsibility to remove
They also found wet organic material, so they used a sump to drain, added fill, and compressed
End result/project is the same as Con Com approved – but since there was a subsurface change, they wanted to inform Con Com and submit a new plan
No fill from Big Dig or Logan can be used on site – must be clean fill; applicant says it will be
No motion needed
Item #11 – DEP File # 59-0823 – 80 & 90 Russell Park – Ron Brodeur presenting update and As-Built in relation to the Enforcement Action from the DEP and Conservation Commission
Ron Brodeur & Robert Hannigan present
Wants to withdraw Amended Order of Conditions and proceed with original Order of Conditions
DEP said it would be ok to do this
He’s having problems with homeless and teenagers destroying property
Con Com said it was ok to go back to original
Item #12 – Enforcement Officer’s report, and requests for appropriation for reimbursement for purchase of high-speed dubber; document signing.
Report: Blue Hills Covered Water Tank is looking for a variance – will be on agenda next meeting; Gregor & McGregor rep to come at a future date to teach to Con Com
Other Business:
1. John Veara – 25 Empire Street – looking for a Certificate of Compliance – had to do a modification to original plan – he sloped all abutters’ land into center – not really clear what, if any, action was taken.
THE NEXT MEETING WILL BE WEDNESDAY, JUNE 18th AT 7:30 P.M.
0 comments | view comments | add comment
|
| Conservation Commission minutes for May 21st, 2003, Tom Palmer, Thu Sep 25 22:23:57 2003 |
Quincy Conservation Commission Meeting Minutes
May 21, 2003
Recorded by Ross Edwards
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Members present:
Suzanne Dixon, Bill Keener (Chair), Tom Kelly, Martha King, James Iorio, Kathy Shaw (late arrival); Heather Sergeant, Enforcement Officer.
_____________________________________________________________________________________
7:30 P.M. Request for Determination of Applicability filed by Paul E. and Joanne E. Casey for the removal of two weeping willow trees on property located at 58 Appleton Street, Quincy, MA. Land Subject to Coastal Storm Flowage.
Action: Unanimously voted that ordinance does apply. Applicant asked to submit plans for compensatory planting of replacement trees.
7:35 P.M. Discussion of Enforcement Order -– Tree Cutting – Robert DiStasio, 132 Washington Street, Quincy, MA. Riverfront Area-Town Brook.
Issue: cutting or trees less than 1.5 inches diameter along Town Brook as part of Mr. DiStasio’s efforts to remove debris from the Brook bed. Tree-cutting was required to gain access to debris in the bed of the brook. This part of Town Brook includes the smelt run, and blockage of this area could threaten flooding of parts of downtown Quincy upstream.
Action: Commission requested that Mr. DiStasio present a plan to the Commission for any future cleanup plans.
7:40 P.M. Notice of Intent filed by Shek Chuen and Millie Chan for the construction of a 318.5 sq. ft. two-story addition and deck to the existing dwelling on property located at 9 Janet Road, Quincy, MA. Land Subject to Coastal Storm Flowage.
No controversial issues. No public comment for or against.
Action: Unanimously approved.
7:50 P.M. Continued Notice of Intent filed by the Department of Public Works for the cutting and removal of phragmites in preparation of restoring the Parkhurst Street saltmarsh, on property located at Winthrop, Parkhurst and Weymouth Streets, Quincy, MA. Bordering Wetlands Vegetation/Phragmites; and Land Subject to Coastal Storm Flowage.
No representative of the Department was in attendance. Issue continued to June 4 meeting.
8:00 P.M. Notice of Intent filed by the Property R. E. Company for the construction of a second story and rear stairway exit to the existing building on property located at 380 Sea Street, Quincy, MA. 100 –Foot Buffer Zone to Bordering Vegetated Wetlands/Saltmarsh Tidal Creek/Land Subject to Coastal Storm Flowage.
No critical issues. No public comment.
Action: Unanimously approved.
8:10 P.M. Notice of Intent filed by Charles Murphy for the razing of the existing single-family dwelling and construction of a FEMA-approved, helical pile foundation and placement of a prefabricated dwelling, same footprint, on property located at 59 Edgewater Drive, Quincy, MA. Land Subject to Coastal Storm Flowage; 100-Foot Buffer Zone of a Coastal Beach/Bank.
Commission has question on details of helical piles and foundation construction. No apparent critical issues.
Action: Unanimous approval.
8:20 P.M. Notice of intent filed by Pat Considine for the legalization of the demolition of the existing dwelling and for the construction of a new, three-family dwelling and garage under, on property located at 94 East Squantum Street, Quincy, MA. 100-Foot Buffer Zone of Bordering Vegetated Wetlands/ Inland Bank/Riverfront Area
Issues: whether proposed construction encroaches the wetland, and concerns that approval of the proposal will lead to approval of additional construction might lead to increased flooding.
Public comment: none for or against, but one nearby resident expressed the above concern about future additional construction in an area that could not support additional building without threat of flooding or encroachment on the wetland. The owner’s representative assured that there was no intent of future construction on the property.
Action: Unanimous approval.
8:30 P.M. Continued Notice of Intent filed by Roy and Maureen Berggren for the razing of an existing single-family dwelling, and construction of a single-family dwelling, and garage on property located at 42-26 Terne Road, Quincy, MA. Coastal Barrier Resource Area (Federal); Barrier Beach; Land Subject to Coastal Storm Flowage.
Issues: Whether building on this acknowledged barrier beach will contribute to erosion of the beach or threatens to exacerbate acknowledged coastal flowage (as opposed to flooding). The Commission was not in agreement on the importance of this issue, with Ms. Dixon expressing strong disapproval of the proposal.
Public comment: adjacent neighbors commented both for and against the proposed construction. One neighbor thought it would affect flooding less than the razed building, while at least one other neighbor, while not opposed to the proposal per se, expressed concern that flooding might be increased. Concern was also expressed over whether additional buildings might be built on the property, which is composed of four plots. Counsel for the owners stated that no additional dwellings would be built on the property.
Action: Approved: five votes in favor, Ms. Dixon opposed.
Additional miscellaneous business was discussed by the Commission.
Adjourned at 9:20 PM.
NEXT MEETING: 7:30 PM WEDNESDAY, JUNE 4, 2003
1 comments | view comments | add comment
|
| Conservation Commission minutes for April 16th, 2003, Tom Palmer, Thu Sep 25 22:09:53 2003 |
Quincy Conservation Commission Meeting Minutes
April 16, 2003
Recorded by Courtney Campbell & Ross Edwards
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Members present:
Sue Dixon, Jim Iorio, Kathy Shaw, Martha King, Tom Kelly (chairing) & Heather Sargent (Enforcement Officer)
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Item #1 – Discussion of Enforcement Actions – 68 Russell Park/Woodward Ave., 94 East Squantum St., and Quincy Housing Authority, off Yardarm Lane.
First and third sites mentioned were discussed briefly
Second site (94 E. Squantum St.) – a building was razed without authorization – lot is in buffer zone, but building was not (although it did encroach upon buffer) – owner didn’t realize he needed an Order of Conditions – owner put up hay bales immediately and Con Com determined that as long as erosion control is in place, he can proceed without penalty.
Item #2 – Request for Determination of Applicability filed by Bill Bray for the construction of a 12’ x 16’ deck with treated wood to the rear of the existing dwelling, including five footings, and one set of stairs, on property located at 69 Botolph Street, Quincy, MA (100-Foot Buffer Zone of Bordering Wetlands Vegetation; Bank; Inland Stream)
New Item – engineer for applicant presenting
No wetlands on property but site may be in buffer zone - a survey may be needed
Kathy Shaw asked where engineer thought wetland line was – engineer said no wetlands were within 50 feet of proposed structure – Kathy reminded him buffer zone is 100 feet
Con Com voted Act does not apply
Item #3 - Continued Notice of Intent filed by Crown Crossing, LLC, for an Abbreviated Notice of Resource Area Determination on property located at Burgin Parkway, bounded by Centre Street, Mitchell Street, Columbia Street, Plain Street, and Penn Street, Quincy, MA (Riverfont Area/Town Brook; Bordering Land Subject to Flooding; Bordering Vegetated Wetlands; Bank; 100-Foot Buffer Zone of Bank/Bordering Vegetated Wetlands)
Continued meeting – site visit was held
Kathy Shaw & Tom Kelly agreed that applicant’s delineation was very good and they were happy with work the applicant had done
Shaw also said that in a previous Order of Conditions for this site there was mention of a Cape Cod berm – she said this condition will carry over into any future Orders of Conditions
Item approved
Item #4 - Continued Notice of Intent filed by Roy and Maureen Berggren for the razing of an existing single-family dwelling, and construction of a single family dwelling, and garage on property located at 42-26 Terne Road, Quincy, MA (Coastal Barrier Resource Area – Federal; Barrier Beach; Land Subject to Coastal Storm Flowage)
Continued item – borings
Michelle Grenier (Wetlands Scientist) representing applicant
4 borings consistent – sand and gravel with some clay – more solid blow counts at 22’-25’
Notification confusion: Abutters were notified after first meeting and after the continuance
DEP did a site visit
Current building to be razed is just a foundation of old house and remains of garage
Salt marsh is already being restored (Broad Meadows Restoration Project) – tide gates are fixed – so the flooding won’t get better
Sue Dixon says there is a hydraulic connection to the marsh
Sue Dixon reported seeing waves go over the sea wall (had pictures too) and maintained that this site is a velocity zone and is a Federal Coastal Barrier System
Johnny Potts – in favor of project – says flooding is caused by trucks packing down earth in area and says lot currently being used by ‘rif-rafs’ drinking
Frank Powers – neighbor across street – wasn’t notified – worried about flooding impact
Christine Valentino (lives nearby) – noticed sponginess of ground, has major flooding and witnessed waves over sea wall – reported that applicant threatened if they didn’t get a permit to build they’d sell the site to developer
1991 – No Name Storm neighbors reporting 4 feet of water in their houses and on street – a boat came over sea wall and floated down the street
Bernadine Hayes – speaking for Diane Furlong and Mary Munson – says Con Com last year approved a house (the McDonalds’ house) built on other side of the street – 26 piles were driven until a site was found that would work - that house is now leaning, the left side has already buckled in past and now the right side vents are buckling out – submitted photos of leaning house
Another abutter who owns 2 lots on same street (1 of which was deemed unbuildable) is worried about flooding
Marge Lynn-Resdyn (47 Tern Road) has no objection to house being built if it’s in the same footprint as original – but noted that the owner of this lot also owns 3 other neighboring sites – fears that if this house is granted, others may follow suit.
Roy Brigham – says he’s never had a problem with flooding – less now than before
Heather Sargent said that CZM was going to examine the property – Quigley says the property is on the barrier and recommends site not be built on – fears increased global warming
Item continued – applicant needs to bring calcs of volume of pile dredgings
Item #5 - Notice of Intent filed by the Department of Public Works for the cutting and removal of phragmities in preparation of restoring the Parkhurst Street saltmarsh, on property located at Winthrop, Parkhurst and Weymouth Streets, Quincy, MA (Bordering Wetlands Vegetation/Phragmities; Land Subject to Coastal Storm Flowage)
New item
Arthur Knowlton presenting
Arthur asked CC what is ideal phragmities cutting season – worried that by cutting now the pollen might spread the phragmities – Sue Dixon will check with CZM for time frame
Arthur showed before & after photos of his cutting and restoration/painting of fence (some wood donated by Rosemary Nolan)
CZM currently doing a study for the Army Corp to repair marsh
Site is 3.2 acres
Arthur asked for a one month period to remove cuttings – granted by CC
Also asked for a continuance to talk to CZM about future cutting to finish his work
Con Com thanked him for his work
Item continued
Item #6 - Notice of Intent filed by the Conroy Development Corporation for the demolition of the on-site Mathewson Corporation building and construction of a 280-unit, 10-story apartment building, including surface parking, landscaping, and utilities, on property located at 2 Hancock Street, Quincy, MA (Neponset River Area of Critical Environmental Concern; Neponset River/Riverfront Area; 100-Foot Buffer Zone of Bank/Neponset River; Land Subject to Flooding/Coastal Storm Flowage)
New item
Jim Torney (lawyer), Fred Keeler (HW Moore), Mary Smith (landscape architect), Terry Conway (contractor) presenting
Currently on site is a flea market building and other various buildings
Site is between the MBTA and Route 3A bridges
Proposed: 280 unit apt bldg – 1/2 1 bdrm, 1/2 2 bdrm (10% affordable housing)
12 stories bottom 2 are for parking
502 total parking spaces – 177 of those are surface spots (not in garage)
Proposed resurfacing of deck on site – currently in disrepair
Proposed building is 62-64 ft further back from river than current bldg (800-1200 sq.ft. more)
No proposed work to rip rap wall in front of site along river
ZBA approved this project
Site is 4.68 acres zoned Industrial B – 3.95 acres covered by current bldgs and pavement, proposed only 3.15 acres will be bldgs and pavement (19,000 sqft more pervious area)
Will use existing outfall system - catch basins with 4’ sumps will be put in – run off will be treated before discharged into river
Applicant says overall it will improve look of area
Mitigation applicant is proposing is $400K-$500K traffic improvements
Met with area environmental groups – those discussions led to some changes in their plan – wider path along river and retaining wall in back of lot
Mary Smith – walkway will have a guardrail - not sure what material walkway will be made of – hopes it will be semi-permeable at least
Cashman was a previous owner of this site
Determined that there were 3 underground tanks on site – 2 have been removed and one has been filled
Noise from T is a consideration for applicant – currently a geotechnical group from Needham is conducting a noise/vibration study
Kathy Shaw was trying to find ways to decrease surface pavement in area - move it back from river or decrease number of spaces – it is within 100-ft buffer zone
1.75 spaces per unit are allotted here
Tom Palmer – generally in favor of project, wants walkway to remain open to public
Bryan Stevens – claimed developer kept Industrial zoning rating for favorable set backs and got a variance to put up a Residential building – also wants parking moved under bridge
Kathy Shaw has seen flooding in the area - site will need to be elevated (adding fill) so flooding in area will worsen
Steve Perdios (Friends of Neponset Estuary) also spoke about moving parking under MBTA bridge – spoke to MBTA and they seemed interested
MBTA owns land under MBTA bridge, MDC owns land under Rt. 3A bridge
There’s already parking under 3A bridge – environmental groups want applicant to move their surface parking under the MBTA bridge – MBTA bridge is steel (3A bridge is concrete) so it will be safer than those spots under the 3A bridge – no pieces falling off, etc.
Applicant said that they met with an MBTA area supervisor and he expressed concerns about liability, access, and lighting/safety - Perdios and Stevens both said those issues were easy to work out and negotiate
Applicant reiterated that this is the best plan they have put forth – claims because MBTA owns land under bridge, they don’t want their parking there
Site visit scheduled for Wednesday, April 30th at 6:00 p.m.
Item continued to next meeting
Item #7 - Continued Notice of Intent filed by Quarry Hills Associates for the construction of a multi-function clubhouse, pedestrian and vehicular access ways, utilities, and other appurtenances, on property located at Quarry Hills Recreational Facility, off Ricciuti Drive, Quincy, MA (100-Foot Buffer Zone of Inland Bank; Land under a Water Body - Goldfish Quarry and Lyons' Quarry)
Continued item – site visit held
Dennis Harrington (lawyer) & Robert Cummings (field engineer) presenting
Location of clubhouse issue
Con Com wants to see a foundation plan for the clubhouse – applicant showed them preliminary not stamped by engineer plans - final foundation plan will not be ready for the next meeting
Hiking trails throughout natural areas of Quarry Hills will be affected by this location change – applicant says similar paths were chosen instead and will be in same spirit of original plan
Con Com wants a new hiking trail plan – Harrington says new hiking plan is not necessary to this project and wants to close tonight
Hiking plan will be ready by next meeting and will be submitted to CC
Tom Palmer – noted that the Environmental Secretary stated that natural/historical sites must be connected by trails, Quarry Hills has a wretched record of compliance, landfill is not yet completely closed (urged this to be closed before approval of clubhouse), methane concerns
Cummings says the closing of the landfill is in progress and does not need to happen before this approval is received and also he said that methane controls are in place in some areas
Item approved with conditions and upon submission of new hiking plan and foundation plan
Item #8 – DEP File #59-0846 Algonquin Gas HubLine – Update by Mike Tyrell and Associates for Work in the Weymouth Fore River.
Mike Tyrell from TRC, and Paul Martin from TRC presenting
Weymouth drilling has been completed successfully – pipe is tied in from Quincy offshore – pipe extends to George’s Island where a tie in still needs to be done
Kathy Shaw reported seeing waves under the Fore River bridge (something uneven about ocean floor – water hitting bump and creating waves) where there were none before
Tom Kelly said some spoil piles are still there after backfilling was done (near Bass Rock – Raccoon Island), concerned that the level of the ground has been raised up, 50’ interval checks could have flaws
These are public safety/boating issues
Mike Tyrell wants CC to point out trouble spots on a map so they can check
Tyrell reported there were some turbidity exceedances – they then went to 24 hour monitoring – fixed now
Other Business:
Nathan Collins (Gale Associates) on behalf of Park & Rec. Dept. – in preparation for Babe Ruth tournament starting 1st week in August he presenting a plan for park improvements to Adams Field – wants to make sure plan is ok to use in his Notice of Intent and he doesn’t have to do a wetlands delineation – plan includes a new 3,000 seat capacity field; new 1500 seat bleacher system; 3-4 transportable bleachers to be relocated after tourney; new bathrooms, pressbox, and concessions (labor will be donated); additional parking – approx 72 spaces (widening existing road 5’); replacing current fence with an 8’ high black coated fence in same footprint – plan approved – item will be on agenda next meeting
Nancy Jolly (Quincy Neighborhood Association) – Con Com on Oct. 3, 2001 granted 6” diameter test borings at Faxon Field (10’-12’ deep) – Chris Carroll said Act did not apply so applicant could get results to put in Notice of Intent – borings needed to be done on frozen ground - CDM began borings winter ‘01-’02 – couldn’t finish because warm winter – finished winter ‘02-’03 – CDM said results would be public, but no results have been given yet – Jolly wants to see the results – Con Com haven’t gotten them yet, but no Notice of Intent can be filed until results are in
Sue Dixon reported that there are stop logs again in Blacks Creek – they’re stopping the water for recreational purposes – she wants to stop boating program in the creek – she wants Con Com to write a letter to Mayor
Heather Sargent said she thinks that the entire site of the 2 Hancock Street project (see Item #6) is a flood plain and thus in the ACEC – but will check
THE NEXT MEETING WILL BE WEDNESDAY, MAY 7th AT 7:30 P.M.
0 comments | view comments | add comment
|
| Conservation Commission Minutes for April 2nd, 2003, Tom Palmer, Thu Sep 25 21:02:52 2003 |
Quincy Conservation Commission Meeting Minutes
April 2, 2003
Recorded by Courtney Campbell & Ross Edwards _____________________________________________________________________________________
Members present:
Sue Dixon (chairing), Jim Iorio, Kathy Shaw, Marcia King, Tom Kelly, Bill Keener, & Heather Sargent (Enforcement Officer)
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Item #1 – Discussion of Enforcement Order issued for 143R Edgewater
Drive
Shawn Hardy, Green Environmental, representing homeowner
Work on this project was stopped due to reports of fill being taken away from this site and crushed material being added
During construction, piles that the house is to be built upon started to sink into the soil too far, so a lot of clay and one truckload of peat was excavated and moved offsite. Crushed stone was brought in and placed in holes so piling has a solid bed to sit on.
Con Com was under the assumption that the helical coils/pilings were to be level with the ground and the foundation was to be poured at grade - not the case - foundation will sit 4 ft below grade - homeowner stated that the Building Dept mandates all foundations be 4 ft. below grade for frost reasons.
Con Com requested new updated plans from homeowner for record and approved them to move forward with the project.
Item #2 – Notice of Intent filed by Roy & Maureen Berggren for the razing of
an existing single-family dwelling, and construction of a single-family dwelling
and garage on property located at 42-26 Terne Road, Quincy, MA (Coastal Barrier
Resource Area - Federal; Barrier Beach; Land Subject to Coastal Storm Flowage)
Michelle Grenier, Allen & Major, representing applicant
Original house on this site burned down 20 years ago - remaining garage was burned by vandals July 4, 2002
Proposed house will be smaller than the footprint of original house
This project appeared before Con Com before and was denied because of the adverse effects to drainage in the area due to proposed flow through foundation and paving
This is same plan, but with 2 alterations - no foundation - house will be on open pile foundation and applicant will be using pervious pavers for driveway and walkway
Reconstruction of the garage is also proposed
First floor of house will be above flood elevation 11' Con Com said whole site in velocity zone - Ms. Grenier says that the area where the house is proposed not in velocity zone according to FEMA - Con Com says FEMA is inaccurate
The sill of the proposed house will sit directly on 12" wooden piles - there will be no pile caps
Applicant has not done borings yet so there's some uncertainty as to whether the foundation will have to go into ground 1' or so for support
Con Com asked that if that happens new plans need to be submitted Con Com gave applicant permission to take 2-6 borings on site
Item continued to next meeting
Item #3 - Continued Notice of Intent filed by the Meadows at Marina Bay, LLC, for the restoration and maintenance of the existing road system on the Historic Squantum Naval Air Station off Seaport Drive in Quincy, MA (100-Foot Buffer Zone of Saltmarsh; Riverfront Area; ACEC-Neponset River; and Land Subject to Coastal Storm Flowage
Item #4 - Continued Notice of Intent filed by Daniel Flaherty for the clearing of trees and vegetation on two lots for the purpose of constructing two 26'x30' single-family dwellings, two driveways, culverting of sixty linear feet of stream, and removal/replication of 1760 sqft of Bordering Vegetated Wetlands, and compensation for all lost flood storage volume, on property located at 124 and 130 Grove Street, Quincy, MA (Riverfront Area/Stream; Bank; Bordering Vegetated Wetlands; 100-Foot Buffer Zone of Bank/Bordering Vegetated Wetlands)
Continued item
Joe Shea and Daniel Flaherty present
Had site visit and inspected/researched 36" drain
Kathy Shaw looked into feasibility of proposed wetland replication - since it will take one year to see any results, applicant will have to come before Con Com next year for inspection - if replication is not working, some other type of compensation will have to be made
Joe Shea said they are working closely with the engineer to make sure proper connections are made to the City's drainage system
Brian Connolly, Ward Councillor, submitted a letter in strong support of project
Item approved with one year checkup on wetland (Tom made motion, Bill seconded)
Item #5 - Continued Notice of Intent filed by Paul and Richard Cleary for the construction of additional parking spaces and modification of a drive-through window at the existing Dunkin' Donuts store at 364 Sea Street, with an appropriate stormwater treatment structure, on property located at 364 to 376 Sea Street, Quincy, MA (Land Subject to Coastal Storm Flowage; 100-Foot Buffer Zone to Saltmarsh)
Continued item
Sam Slyman, engineer, present
Had site visit
This site previously had 2 single family houses on it before Dunkin Donuts was built
Plans are with the engineering dept for them to approve the connections to the existing drainage system - haven't been approved by them yet, but Slyman doesn't foresee any problems
Item approved (Jim made motion, Bill seconded)
Item #6 - Notice of Intent filed by Crown Crossing, LLC, for an Abbreviated Notice of Resource Area Determination on property located at Burgin Parkway, bounded by Centre Street, Mitchell Street, Columbia Street, Plain Street, and Penn Street, Quincy, MA (Riverfront Area/Town Brook; Bordering Land Subject to Flooding; Bordering Vegetated Wetlands; and Bank; 100-Foot Buffer Zone of Bank/Bordering Vegetated Wetlands)
Item #7 - Continued Notice of Intent filed by Quarry Hills Associates for the construction of a multi-function clubhouse, pedestrian and vehicular access ways, utilities, and other appurtenances, on property located at Quarry Hills Recreational Facility, off Ricciuti Drive, Quincy, MA (100-Foot Buffer Zone of Inland Bank; Land under a Water Body - Goldfish Quarry and Lyons' Quarry)
THE NEXT MEETING WILL BE WEDNESDAY, APRIL 16th AT 7:30 P.M.
0 comments | view comments | add comment
|
| March 19, 2003, Steve Perdios, Tue Apr 1 16:57:58 2003 |
Quincy Conservation Commission Meeting Notes
March 19, 2003
Recorded by Courtney Campbell & Ross Edwards
_______________
Members present:
Sue Dixon (chairing), Kathy Shaw, Bill Keener, Jim Iorio, & Heather Sergeant (Enforcement Officer)
______________
Item #1 – Request for Determination for Applicability filed by William and Lynda Everett for the removal of a deck and construction of an addition to the existing dwelling on property located at 37 Vassall Street, Quincy, MA (Bordering Land Subject to Flooding; 100-Foot Buffer Zone of Sachem Brook)
Ø New item
Ø Linda Everett present
Ø Proposal is for 14' x 28' addition with a full basement
Ø Since property is 10' elevation and below flood leve1 (12'), can't have basement
Ø Because Sachem Brook is culverted, the 100-ft buffer zone does not apply
Ø Applicant will have to research the basement rule and file a Notice of Intent
Ø Act does apply - Kathy made motion, Jim seconded
Item #2 – Request for Determination for Applicability filed by the Germantown Neighborhood Center on behalf of the City of Quincy School Dept for the conducting of soil borings on property located at 333 Palmer Street, Quincy, MA (100-Foot Buffer Zone of Swamp/Bordering Vegetated Wetland)
Ø New item
Ø Emilio Favorito from City Planning Dept present representing School Dept, YMCA, and Germantown community group that facilitates operations at Snug Harbor School
Ø Proposal is for 3 borings to determine soil conditions for planning structural design
Ø Public neighborhood meeting was held 3/20 - proposal was well received by the community
Ø Applicant will have to file a Notice of Intent in order to discuss future building plan
Ø Act does not apply - Jim made motion, Kathy seconded
Item #3 – Notice of Intent filed by Roy and Maureen Berggren for the razing of an existing single-family dwelling, and construction of a single-family dwelling, and garage on property located at 42-26 Terne Road, Quincy, MA (Coastal Barrier Resource Area - Federal; Barrier Beach; Land Subject to Coastal Storm Flowage)
Ø Item immediately continued to April 2nd meeting
Item #4 – Request for Determination of Applicability filed by Stephen Burgio for the conducting of soil borings on property located at 15 Freca Road, Quincy, MA (Land Subject to Coastal Storm Flowage #401; Riverfront Area/tidal creek; Land Subject to Flooding)
Ø New item
Ø Richard Stewart and applicant present
Ø Proposal is for soil borings in preparation for a proposal to demolish one house and construct a new house
Ø Stewart wanted to show Con Com conceptual house designs but they said to wait and submit under Notice of Intent
Ø Act does not apply - Jim made motion, Bill seconded
Item #5 - Continued Notice of Intent filed by Daniel Flaherty for the clearing of trees and vegetation on two lots for the purpose of construting two 26'x30' single-family dwellings, two driveways, culverting of sixty linear feet of stream, and removal/replication of 1760 sqft of Bordering Vegetated Wetlands, and compensation for all lost flood storage volume, on property located at 124 and 130 Grove Street, Quincy, MA (Riverfront Area/Stream; Bank; Bordering Vegetated Wetlands; 100-Foot Buffer Zone of Bank/Bordering Vegetated Wetlands)
Ø Continued item - site visit was held on 3/8
Ø Daniel Flaherty and Joe Shea present
Ø 65 trees are flagged on site for removal - Sue Dixon asked of those how many were deciduous trees - applicant did not know
Ø Applicant decided to go with an enclosed culvert instead of an open channel
Ø Wetland Scientist for proposal is Mary Rimmer
Ø Kathy Shaw questioned the feasibility of freshwater replication - she says it doesn't seem to be working in select sites - wants more time to look into this
Ø Applicant wanted to close meeting tonight - Jim Iorio suggested having the Order of Conditions ready at next meeting
Ø Item continued to April 2nd meeting - Jim made motion, Bill seconded
Item #6 - Notice of Intent filed by Paul and Richard Cleary for the construction of additional parking spaces and modification of a drive-through window at the existing Dunkin' Donuts store at 364 Sea Street, with an appropriate stormwater treatment structure, on property located at 364 to 376 Sea Street, Quincy, MA (Land Subject to Coastal Storm Flowage; 100-Foot Buffer Zone to Saltmarsh)
Ø New item
Ø Sam Slyman (engineer), Richard Cleary (owner), Paul Lovitto (wetland scientist/LEC) present
Ø Proposal is two parts - one is to pave area next to store in order to add 16 more parking spots, and second is to extend drive-thru around this new parking area to allow 13 cars to cue instead of the current 5 alleviating traffic on street
Ø Salt marsh (Turn Marsh) is located directly behind this site - new drive-thru would have cars driving alongside the marsh (6 ft from wall) - Lovitto claims because phragmities invaded the marsh, it's no longer a marsh at all - Con Com will decide resource area line during site visit
Ø Mention was made that new high school proposal that will come before Con Com has as its compensation, repair and restoration of this Turn Marsh - so if it's not one now, it may soon be
Ø A 3-4 ft retaining wall separates the marsh from the site
Ø Haybales and silt fences will be used around marsh during construction
Ø The land they're proposing to pave is what applicant calls "idle land" where junk is thrown
Ø They will install pipes to collect runoff and will connect to existing drainage system
Ø Part of the site is within the 100-year flood zone
Ø Peter Fifield, abutter, spoke in opposition - asked if retaining wall was strong enough to withstand extra cars driving alongside it and also mentioned a fire that started in the marsh last January probably from a cigarette thrown from a car going through drive thru
Ø John Evans spoke in favor - he's for getting the cars cueing for the drive thru off the street
Ø Greg Hanley, Ward I Councilor, is in favor
Ø Item continued, site visit scheduled for 3/22, 9 am - Jim made motion, Bill seconded
Item #7 - Continued Notice of Intent filed by the Meadows at Marina Bay, LLC, for the restoration and maintenance of the existing road system on the Historic Squantum Naval Air Station off Seaport Drive in Quincy, MA (100-Foot Buffer Zone of Saltmarsh; Riverfront Area; ACEC-Neponset River; and Land Subject to Coastal Storm Flowage
Ø Item immediately continued to April 2nd meeting
Item #8 - Continued Notice of Intent filed by Elder Housing, LLC, for the redevelopment of a previously developed site for a 223-unit affordable senior housing apartment community with associated utilities and infrastructure, on property located at 390-424 East Squantum Street, Quincy, MA (Riverfront Area; ACEC-Neponset River; Land Subject to Coastal Storm Flowage)
Ø Continued item - had site visit on 3/8
Ø Dennis Harrington, Dennis Lowry (NSAR wetland ecologist), and John McKenin (P.E. at HW Moore) present
Ø Harrington pressed Con Com to decide tonight so they could get all permitting done so HUD could start to fund project
Ø CZM, Chapter 91, and MEPA have already approved project and issued permits
Ø Sue Dixon wants CZM to be informed of soils results
Ø NepRWA contacted Harrington about an opportunity to restore natural vegetation and to create a pedestrian path along Billings Creek - Bryan Stevens presented NepRWA's ideas
Ø NepRWA's not opposed to project because most work is outside the resource areas on the site
Ø Applicant is already proposing to restore natural vegetation, although NepRWA would like to see more - Lowry summarized proposed plantings on site
Ø Path would connect Airport Road to a private way that the City owns
Ø Path would be for recreation and public access, bike riding and dog walking were discussed - Sue Dixon against either of those two uses because of the close proximity to elderly citizens, also Harrington voiced a concern about "rowdy teenagers" using the path
Ø Path would require bringing soils from one side of site to the other
Ø NepRWA is willing to help fund or fund all of this path project
Ø Tom Palmer concurred with Bryan Stevens and also compared Quincy to other areas including Boston in terms of public access to the waterfront - Quincy's way behind
Ø Tom stated that this path would be part of a bigger effort by NepRWA to have a corridor of open space along the river
Ø Tom also mentioned 2 fences that limit public access to waterfront
Ø The Chairman of Elder Housing is willing to talk to NepRWA, but not willing to pay any more
Ø Applicant concerned that implementation of this path into the current project would require re-permitting because promises were made that no work would be done in resource areas
Ø Sue Dixon seemed vehemently against the path idea - angry that NepRWA isn't content that this is a good proposal for elderly
Ø Path doesn't have to be pavement
Ø Kathy Shaw wants one of the fences on site to be taken down - Harrington said ok - the other separates Miles Standish School playground from site and should stay
Ø Item approved - Jim made motion, Kathy seconded
Item #9 - Notice of Intent filed by Quarry Hills Associates for the construction of a multi-function clubhouse, pedestrian and vehicular access ways, utilities, and other appurtenances, on property located at Quarry Hills Recreational Facility, off Ricciuti Drive, Quincy, MA (100-Foot Buffer Zone of Inland Bank; Land under a Water Body - Goldfish Quarry and Lyons' Quarry)
Ø Item immediately continued to April 2nd meeting
Item #10 - Continued Notice of Intent filed by the South Shore YMCA for the expansion of parking facilities and stormwater controls on property located at 79 Coddington Street and 116 McGrath Highway, Quincy, MA (Land Subject to Flooding; Bordering Vegetated Wetlands; and 100-Foot Buffer Zone of Bordering Vegetated Wetlands)
Ø Continued item - site visit was made 3/8
Ø Sean Hardy and Dave Hickey from Green Environmental present
Ø Area they're proposing for additional parking requires 30 cubic yards of filling in flood area
Ø Applicant claims that their compensation is 7:1 - hollowing out 200 more cubic yards of existing detention basin
Ø There has been a hydraulic connection between neighboring properties and this site
Ø Kathy Shaw asked if permeable material could be used to fill proposed additional parking instead of paving to allow more water to sink in and seep up
Ø Applicant claims that the heavy year round use would have problems with a permeable material - especially in winter with plowing, etc. - but says that the pervious pipes underground should be able to accommodate the flood waters
Ø Trees will be placed to act as a buffer between parking area and neighbors - will also soak up some water
Ø Fertilizer and pesticides are applied 3 times a year - no herbicides are used says applicant - Joe Cotter spoke in opposition to this fertilizing - says unless agents are organic, there might be some potential carcinogens that could pose a threat to children in area - sited Marblehead which is now exclusively using organic agents - Bill Aylwood wanted this to be a condition in the Order of Conditions - Kathy Shaw also expressed a concern on this matter - poor drainage in area may allow harmful agents to accumulate - applicant said they would be open to talking to Joe Cotter and others to discuss alternatives
Ø Greg Hanley spoke in favor - says YMCA is a non-profit that does the right thing - noted in the past catch basins were not maintained properly - Green Environmental has a good track record on maintenance so this should not be an issue now.
Ø Nancy Jolly spoke in opposition - flooding issue continues and approving this project will make flooding in her neighborhood (Woodward Ave.) worse - had meeting with Mayor Phelan, Hanley, and Gutro at her house in Jan. 02 informing them of the flooding problem, and can't believe that Hanley is in favor of this project
Ø Sue Dixon responded to Nancy Jolly by saying that if the applicant proposes appropriate compensation for filling in land in a resource area, then they cannot deny it because DEP will override their decision - since applicant is compensating 7:1 they cannot deny
Ø Item approved - Kathy made motion, Jim seconded - a condition about catch basin maintenance will be included in Order of Conditions.
Other Business:
Ø Greg Hanley mentioned a complaint by David Tandy involving sand that is working its way onto his land. It seems to be related to Algonquin's activities in laying the natural gas pipeline across Quincy bay. Hanley asked the Commission what is being done to monitor Algonquin's activities. He was told that Algonquin will be here to report at the next meeting. Shaw suggests that Tandy see the Duke Energy web site for where to call to file a complaint. Con Com: "We had a feeling that this type of thing might happen."
Ø Greg Hanley also mentioned 2-3 abutters of the Snug Harbor School addition (Item #2 above, 333 Palmer St.), who had reservations that approached him during this meeting. Mr. Adams approached Hanley saying that he now cannot sell his property because of abutting deteriorating sea walls. Peter Kolson, former Ward 1 councilor, had been involved in an attempt to replace the sea walls. At the time people were told that those sea walls could no longer be rebuilt to be compliant with standards because the "No-Name" storm had eroded under the entire property. Heather Sergeant and Kathy Shaw stated the FEMA may have money for such cases, that Mr. Adams should talk to FEMA about a program for putting in "sand barriers combined with replanting."
Ø Courtney Campbell made a three-point statement to the Commission: (1) She noted an apparent "fear" by the Commission of being overridden by the DEP. Dixon and Shaw responded that they are not afraid, but, rather, they are coming to learn what the Commission can and cannot properly do. For example, the YMCA proposal meets the law regarding compensation for proposed filling of a wetland. (2) When suggestions are made, e.g., regarding trees and pesticides, are these suggestions actually included in the Order of Conditions? Commission members responded that it depends on what is allowed to be in the Order. Often, these suggestions are beyond what is (legally) required. (3) She noted that sometimes public comment seems to be cut off prematurely. She stated that sometimes we need a bit more time to digest the immediate events of the meeting and to generate a response. The Commissions response was that most public commenters are prepared in advance with their comments, and that the problem often is to cut off excessive repetitions of ideas by overly zealous commenters. Note that anyone can submit material in writing after the meeting.
THE NEXT MEETING WILL BE WEDNESDAY, APRIL 2nd AT 7:30 P.M.
0 comments | view comments | add comment
|
|
 |