Quincy Environmental Network
Home Events News Volunteer Links Government Organization
Candidate Responses Brian McNamee / candidate for Ward Six, City Council

View The Questions

JoAnn M. Bragg
Councilor-at-large

Kevin Coughlin
Ward Three, City Council

Joseph G. Finn
Councilor-at-large

Alicia Gardner
Ward Six, City Council

Jimmy Liang
Councilor-at-large

Frank McCauley
Councilor-at-large

Brian McNamee
Ward Six, City Council

William J. Phelan
Mayor

1) Leading environmental concerns for Quincy would include:

The Water Quality at Wollaston Beach

We would enjoy significant quality of life benefits if we could address remaining contributors of pollution to Wollaston Beach. Specifically, we need to identify and replace any sewer lines that are broken and leaching into storm water collection systems.

The City of Quincy needs to meet the EPA's Capacity, Management, Operation, and Maintenance (CMOM) requirements for sewer lines. Such compliance will insure Quincy's collection system does not contribute to water pollution (ground water or otherwise). Most of the City Sewer lines are over 100 years old and are made of aging vitrified clay. The system needs to be mapped. Once mapped the system needs to be inspected. After a thorough inspection a replacement prioritization plan needs to be put into effect. First priority would address sanitary sewer overflows (SSOs) with human and health impacts. This is part of the city's responsibility to insure our aging infrastructure is not contributing to water pollution at Wollaston beach or any pollution of ground water.

In addition to the clean water objectives of CMOM for Municipal Sanitary Sewer Systems. Storm water flowing from storm drains is a leading contributor to pollution at Wollaston Beach. Where particularly difficult pollution sources exist we need to explore the feasibility of storm water treatment systems before the storm water is released onto the beach. The treatment of storm run-off is becoming more common and has reduced pollution in many rivers and streams. Although treatment of storm run-off has historically been expensive and land intensive, newer technologies have created more opportunities to treat storm water. It should be noted on July 30 Quincy was required to file a storm water management plan to state and federal environmental agencies with the objective of keeping local beaches clean.

Open Space Preservation

We need to preserve what little open space we have left in the City of Quincy. Particularly in North Quincy we need to fight against further development of Lot 23 at Marina Bay. In addition, moneys should be set aside to clean up the Dickinson property at the entranceway to Marina Bay. I think we can do a little bit better than to have Jersey Barriers as boundary markers to this property.

Open Space moneys need to be utilized to clean up Squaw Rock to make it more accessible to all the residents of North Quincy. While there is still a trickle of "Big Dig" fill being produced we would be wise to utilize that dirt to fill the large excavation hole at Squaw Rock. This hole currently creates a large hazard to anyone being able to safely navigate the Squaw Rock area.

Finally, we need to lobby Quincy's elected state officials to complete the plans for Squantum Point Park. Squantum Point park with its beautiful vistas of the Boston skyline and the harbor still represents one of Ward 6's most unfulfilled open space projects.

Air Pollution

It should be no surprise that one of the most pressing environmental issues facing Quincy is an issue facing the Nation. Air Pollution continues to be a National concern. According to the American Lung Association (ALA) nearly 335,000 lives are lost each year in the United States due to lung disease. The ALA reports air pollution is a significant contributing factor to lung disease.

Our automobile culture and the number of motor vehicles in the urban environment has contributed significantly to poor air quality. We need to emphasis public transportation, car-pooling, and automobile power systems that utilize alternatives to fossil fuels.

Despite the number of limitations we face locally to address this issue we can start by taking small steps to control air pollution. One area that is certainly addressable at the local level, is to control idling school buses, particularly diesel powered buses. Measurements of air quality at schoolyards and adjacent areas during times when school buses are arriving and departing have produced startling results. This is of particular concern when once considers the body weight and lung capacity of young children. Because of a child's size and lung capacity the smallest amount of inhaled emissions can have a detrimental effect. Certainly, we can adopt no idle policies for vehicles in school zone to address this perfectly preventable passive exposure.

2)(a)  This question touches upon what has become a highly politicized issue for Quincy.

Given some of the state and local financial uncertainties that have arisen since the new high school was proposed, renovation options might now be more attractive.

When it was more clear, at an earlier time, that we were going to receive 90 percent reimbursement from the state this was a more attractive undertaking. With the state facing unprecedented financial pressures this is an entirely different situation today. State revenue projections have fallen short of expectations and as everyone knows these shortfalls have resulted in cuts to local aid to cities and towns.

I believe the following is a fair assessment of what we know and what we don't know:

The city has yet to file all required paper work with the state so the high school project can be formally approved.

The city has been given two extensions to get the required paper work submitted. Our inability to meet state deadlines may effect what we may be reimbursed.

Because the site chosen has some wetland issues, the costs associated with restoring the wetlands and insuring against adjacent flooding do not fall in a state reimbursable category.

We will not receive 90 percent reimbursement for all costs related to this project. According to the Quincy Taxpayers' Association the reimbursement projection is 72%. Not only do we not know how much we will be reimbursed, we do not know when we will be reimbursed.

To the best of my knowledge, no one has produced a cash flow model outlining a schedule of Quincy's debt service payments matched against a schedule of state reimbursement receipts (using alternative scenarios for "best", "expected", and "worst" case payment/reimbursement timing differences). We need to know the timing of such project revenues and expenditures so as not to have this project adversely impact city finances. As we all know, any adverse impact on city finances will have to be born by the taxpayer through higher taxes. Finally, because of the passage of time since the original construction cost estimate, we know that the project in its final form will cost more than the $110,000,000 estimate.

The variables outlined above shed new light on the wisdom to build a new high school. We need to remember in June of 1997 the Building Needs Task Force estimated renovating Central Middle School for 7 Million and renovating Quincy High School for 8 Million. In current dollars, how attractive would renovation options be versus the current set of uncertainties we face?

In light of all of the above, I cannot, at this time, definitively say the city needs a newly built high school.

(b)  This question is built on a faulty supposition. It assumes the city is not a wholly owned enterprise of the public. The city is "us". We elect the officials, we pay the taxes. Through our collective efforts we, the citizens of Quincy, are The City. Therefore, I'm not sure I understand a question that asks what should we give ourselves after "we" build a new high school? Presumably the answer is, you just gave yourself a new high school!

Regrettably, the utilization of open space is one of the things we sacrifice to have a new high school!

3)(a)  Some of Quincy's largest expanses of open space are in Ward 6. Lot 23, Squantum Point Park, and Squaw Rock come to mind. As discussed in an earlier question I would like to see Squaw Rock cleaned up with these moneys. I would also like to see the MDC's successor entity complete all the phases originally planned by the MDC for Squantum Point Park. If the plans dies with the MDC's abolition, then I would like to see the land conveyed to the city and the original plan bought to its completion.

(b)  I do not think the city does a very good job in collecting excise taxes on business equipment. Certainly, in today's information age there are a lot of people who operate businesses out of their home. If they do, we should be collecting excise tax on their business equipment. This is not being unfriendly to business. Cities and towns do this all over the Commonwealth – it's just a matter of how well they do it. The City Treasurer should send a questionnaire to all businesses operating in Quincy (regardless of where the business is operated) and have them identify their business equipment, the acquisition date of the equipment, and the equipment's cost. If we can produce any marginal enhancement to Quincy's tax revenue in this manner, than why not dedicate a fixed percentage to a city land acquisition account?

There is one thing we should not do. Once we identify the additional revenue stream from improving business equipment excise tax collections we should not do what the city did with the hotel/motel tax revenues. The city showed poor financial discipline and did something for short-term political gain at the expense of the long-term financial interest of the city. These revenue streams if properly managed can be used to build a stabilization fund. If we have a future urgent financial needs we will have financial reserves to cushion the blow to tax payers. Alternatively, if we decide to buy open space we will have funds already set aside.

To go out and acquire long-term debt that will be paid off by these revenue streams is short sighted.

4)  Im not sure I accept as a general rule the belief ward councilors often decide issues that impact the environment of their ward. Perhaps their lead is followed in the context of the PUD process. There are, however, other institutional players who decide ward level environmental impacts. The mayor, for example, played a pivotal role in the acquisition of Squantum Gardens. We also need to recognize the significant roles played by the citys Conservation Commission and the states Department of Environmental Protection.

Putting aside the built-in premises of this question, as a ward councilor all positions on issues should first be addressed in terms of what is in the interest of the ward. After all, Quincy has three at-large councilors and a powerful chief executive who represent the interests of the city as a whole. Why have a ward councilor if that individual is not going to advocate strongly for the interests of the ward?

After I have first considered the interests of my ward, I will then fully consider citywide impacts. If city and ward interests are in conflict only then should the interests of the ward yield to the interests of the city. In the final analysis, no part of the city should be more important than the whole city.

5)  
As with any other dispute regarding performance under a contract. The city should sue for specific performance of contractual obligations.

I trust the EPA is a better authority than I am on environment impacts from the golf course's construction. If environmental damage is proven, I am confident the EPA will use existing laws to fine and/or have QHA mitigate that damage.

If QHA received more dirt that the original $100,000,000 tipping contract we should be exploring our legal right to any of the additional revenue. Naturally, the successful exercise of our rights would depend on the original contract language (which I am not privy to) and whether QHA were enriched beyond the purview of the original agreement.

6)  I'm not sure a sub-committee is required. Certainly, we could expand the role of the Conservation Commission and add a full-time conservation enforcement officer with some real powers to fine.

I do not think we have to add bureaucracy. I think we have some institutions already in place that perhaps need to have their roles expanded.

7)  Existing zoning already permits too much density.

With out knowing what other communities are doing in this area, I honestly do not know what an acceptable standard is. Fifty units to a little over 2 acres seems quite dense.

8)  I'm assuming you are referring to the Quincy Conservation Commission. I am not aware of a Conservation Committee.

Yes, broadening the ordinance governing the Conservation Commission is a good idea. In fact, I would like to see the full-time conservation enforcement officer work with the MWRA's monitoring and enforcement people. There are many clean water benefits to having a municipal level enforcement officer. For example, who is more likely to immediately identify illegal dumping in surface drains? It would most likely be a local enforcement officer.

This is something worth further exploration.


Top of Page
home |  events |  news |  links |  volunteer |  government |  organization